INNO fibre optic temperature sensors ,temperature monitoring systems.
Introduction
Temperature monitoring is a critical aspect of dry-type power transformer management. Excessive temperatures can significantly accelerate insulation aging, with every 8-10°C increase above rated temperature potentially halving the transformer’s operational life. Moreover, thermal hotspots can lead to catastrophic failures, resulting in unplanned outages, expensive repairs, and potential safety hazards.
Dry-type transformers, which use air or solid insulation instead of oil, present unique temperature monitoring challenges. Their cooling efficiency is generally lower than oil-immersed units, making accurate temperature measurement particularly crucial. Additionally, the high-voltage, high-electromagnetic field environment severely limits the effectiveness of conventional temperature monitoring approaches.
This analysis examines the three most effective temperature sensing technologies currently available for dry-type transformer winding applications: fluorescent fiber optic sensors, PT100 resistance temperature detectors (RTDs), and infrared thermal imaging. Each technology offers distinct advantages and limitations that must be carefully considered when designing temperature monitoring systems for critical power infrastructure.
Key Temperature Sensing Technologies for Dry-Type Transformer Windings
1. Fluorescent Fiber Optic Temperature Sensors
Working Principle
Fluorescent fiber optic temperature sensors utilize specialized phosphors (typically rare-earth materials) bonded to the tip of optical fibers. When excited by light pulses, these phosphors emit fluorescent light with a decay time that varies precisely with temperature. The monitoring system measures this decay time to determine the exact temperature at the sensor tip with exceptional accuracy.
Application in Transformer Windings
These sensors can be directly embedded within transformer windings during manufacturing, allowing for true hot-spot measurement at the most critical locations. Multiple sensors can be installed throughout the windings to create a comprehensive thermal profile. The all-optical nature of these sensors means they are completely immune to electromagnetic interference, making them ideal for high-voltage environments.
Advantages:
- Complete electromagnetic immunity – Operates reliably in the intense electromagnetic fields present in transformer windings
- Direct hot-spot measurement – Can be embedded directly at critical points within windings
- Exceptional accuracy – Typically ±1°C across the entire measurement range
- Wide temperature range – Typically -40°C to +260°C, covering all transformer operating conditions
- No calibration drift – Maintains accuracy without recalibration for 25+ years
- No signal deterioration – Immune to light intensity variations from fiber bending or connector losses
- Electrically non-conductive – No risk of electrical discharge or flashover
Limitations:
- Higher initial cost – More expensive than basic RTD systems
- Must be installed during manufacturing – Cannot typically be retrofitted to existing transformers
- Specialized equipment required – Needs specific signal processing units for temperature reading
2. PT100 Resistance Temperature Detectors (RTDs)
Working Principle
PT100 RTDs operate based on the principle that the electrical resistance of platinum changes predictably with temperature. The “100” designates the sensor’s resistance of 100 ohms at 0°C. As temperature increases, resistance increases in a near-linear relationship. By passing a small current through the RTD and measuring the resulting voltage, the temperature can be calculated with good precision.
Application in Transformer Windings
In dry-type transformers, PT100 sensors are typically installed in accessible locations within or near the windings. However, due to their electrical nature, they cannot be placed directly at the hottest spots without specialized isolation. They are often used with thermal models that estimate hot-spot temperatures based on measurements at more accessible points.
Advantages:
- Well-established technology – Industry standard with broad familiarity
- Good accuracy – Typically ±0.3°C to ±0.5°C under ideal conditions
- Reasonable cost – Lower initial investment than fiber optic systems
- Wide temperature range – Typically -200°C to +850°C
- Simple integration – Compatible with standard industrial control systems
Limitations:
- Electromagnetic sensitivity – Susceptible to interference in high-voltage environments
- Limited placement options – Cannot be placed directly at winding hot spots without complex isolation
- Electrically conductive – Requires careful isolation from high-voltage components
- Lead wire resistance – Can affect accuracy unless compensated with 3-wire or 4-wire connections
- Regular calibration required – Sensor drift necessitates periodic recalibration
- Self-heating errors – Current flowing through the sensor can cause minor measurement errors
3. Infrared Thermal Imaging
Working Principle
Infrared thermal imaging detects the infrared radiation emitted by objects and converts this information into temperature values. The technology uses specialized cameras with infrared-sensitive detectors to create visual maps of surface temperatures, with different colors or shades representing different temperature levels.
Application in Transformer Windings
For dry-type transformers, infrared cameras are used primarily for periodic inspection rather than continuous monitoring. They can detect surface temperature patterns and anomalies on accessible parts of the transformer, including terminations and external surfaces of windings. Some installations include permanently mounted infrared cameras for continuous monitoring of accessible surfaces.
Advantages:
- Non-contact measurement – No physical contact with high-voltage components required
- Visual temperature mapping – Provides comprehensive visualization of temperature distributions
- Detects patterns and anomalies – Can identify unusual heating patterns indicating problems
- No installation within windings required – Can be used on existing transformers
- Portable options available – Hand-held cameras allow flexible inspection
Limitations:
- Surface measurements only – Cannot measure internal winding temperatures directly
- Limited by line-of-sight – Cannot see through enclosures or insulation
- Emissivity variations – Different materials and surfaces require calibration adjustments
- Environmental factors – Affected by ambient conditions and reflections
- Moderate accuracy – Typically ±2°C or 2% of reading, less precise than contact methods
- High-end systems expensive – Precision thermal imaging systems have significant costs
Comparative Analysis
When selecting temperature sensing technology for dry-type transformer windings, several key factors must be considered, including accuracy, reliability in high-electromagnetic environments, installation requirements, maintenance needs, and long-term cost of ownership. The following table provides a comprehensive comparison of the three leading technologies based on critical performance parameters:
| Parameter | Fluorescent Fiber Optic Sensors | PT100 RTDs | Infrared Thermal Imaging |
|---|---|---|---|
| Temperature Range | -40°C to +260°C | -200°C to +850°C | -20°C to +500°C (typical cameras) |
| Accuracy | ±1°C across full range | ±0.3°C to ±0.5°C (without EMI) | ±2°C or 2% of reading |
| EMI Immunity | Complete (all optical) | Poor (susceptible to interference) | Good (remote measurement) |
| Direct Hot-Spot Measurement | Yes (can be embedded in windings) | Limited (requires isolation) | No (surface measurement only) |
| Long-Term Stability | Excellent (25+ years without recalibration) | Moderate (periodic recalibration required) | Good (annual calibration recommended) |
| Installation Complexity | High (must be installed during manufacturing) | Moderate | Low (external mounting only) |
| Continuous Monitoring Capability | Excellent | Good | Limited (fixed cameras) to Poor (periodic inspections) |
| Number of Measurement Points | Multiple points possible (4-16 typical) | Limited by accessibility and isolation requirements | Full surface mapping of visible areas |
| Initial Cost | High | Moderate | Moderate to High |
| Maintenance Requirements | Minimal (no recalibration needed) | Moderate (periodic recalibration) | Moderate (lens cleaning, periodic calibration) |
| Lifetime Cost of Ownership | Moderate (high initial cost, low maintenance) | Moderate (lower initial cost, higher maintenance) | Moderate to High (equipment replacement, labor for inspections) |
| Suitability for Critical Applications | Excellent | Good | Fair (supplementary role) |
Application Scenarios
The optimal temperature sensing technology depends significantly on the specific application scenario and critical requirements:
For New Transformer Installations
For new dry-type transformer installations, particularly in critical applications where reliability is paramount, fluorescent fiber optic sensing technology represents the gold standard. The ability to embed sensors directly at winding hot spots during manufacturing provides the most accurate temperature monitoring possible. While the initial investment is higher, the exceptional reliability, EMI immunity, and maintenance-free operation over decades result in superior protection and potentially lower lifetime costs.
For Existing Transformer Monitoring
For existing transformers where internal sensor installation is not possible, a combination approach often yields the best results. PT100 RTDs can be installed at accessible locations with appropriate isolation, while periodic infrared thermal imaging can provide complementary data on external temperature patterns. This combined approach, while not as accurate as embedded fiber optic sensors, can still provide valuable temperature information for condition monitoring and overload protection.
For Critical Power Infrastructure
For transformers in critical power infrastructure—such as those serving hospitals, data centers, or essential industrial processes—the highest level of temperature monitoring reliability is required. In these scenarios, fluorescent fiber optic technology is strongly recommended for new installations, as the consequences of transformer failure far outweigh the additional upfront investment in superior monitoring capability.
FJINNO: Leading the Way in Fluorescent Fiber Optic Temperature Sensing
Among manufacturers of fluorescent fiber optic temperature sensing technology, FJINNO stands out as a technological leader with solutions specifically optimized for transformer applications. Founded in 2011, FJINNO has rapidly established itself as an innovator in advanced temperature monitoring systems for critical electrical infrastructure.
FJINNO’s temperature monitoring systems utilize proprietary fluorescent technology that provides exceptional accuracy (±1°C) across a wide temperature range (-40°C to +260°C). Their transformer monitoring solutions feature:
- Advanced Rare-Earth Phosphor Technology: Utilizing specialized phosphors with temperature-dependent fluorescence lifetime properties that remain stable for decades
- Polyimide-Protected Sensors: Aerospace-grade polyimide coating provides excellent chemical resistance and mechanical durability in transformer environments
- Purpose-Designed Installation Systems: Specialized mounting and routing solutions for optimal positioning within transformer windings
- Comprehensive Monitoring Software: Advanced software for real-time temperature monitoring, trending, and alarm management with SCADA integration capabilities
- Factory Calibration: Pre-calibrated sensors that maintain accuracy for 25+ years without recalibration
FJINNO’s systems have been deployed in critical power transformers worldwide, with an exceptional track record of reliability. Their expertise in transformer applications ensures optimal sensor placement for true hot-spot monitoring, providing transformer operators with unprecedented visibility into actual winding conditions.
For new dry-type transformer installations where reliability and accurate temperature monitoring are critical, FJINNO’s fluorescent fiber optic temperature sensing technology represents the most advanced solution available, offering unmatched performance in challenging electromagnetic environments.
Conclusion
Temperature monitoring is a critical aspect of dry-type transformer management, directly impacting operational safety, reliability, and asset lifespan. Of the three leading technologies examined—fluorescent fiber optic sensors, PT100 RTDs, and infrared thermal imaging—each offers distinct advantages for specific applications.
Fluorescent fiber optic technology emerges as the superior solution for new transformer installations, particularly in critical applications, due to its exceptional electromagnetic immunity, direct hot-spot measurement capability, outstanding long-term stability, and maintenance-free operation. While the initial investment is higher than alternative technologies, the superior protection it provides to valuable transformer assets and the lower lifetime maintenance costs justify this investment for critical power infrastructure.
PT100 RTDs continue to serve as a reliable and cost-effective solution for less critical applications or as supplementary sensors in accessible locations. Infrared thermal imaging provides valuable complementary data, particularly for existing installations where internal sensors cannot be retrofitted.
For operators of dry-type transformers seeking the highest level of temperature monitoring reliability, FJINNO’s advanced fluorescent fiber optic technology represents the current state of the art, offering unmatched performance in the challenging electromagnetic environment of transformer windings. By enabling true hot-spot temperature monitoring with exceptional accuracy and long-term stability, this technology provides transformer operators with the data they need to optimize loading, prevent failures, and extend asset life.
The choice of temperature sensing technology should be carefully evaluated based on the specific requirements of each application, with consideration given to factors including criticality, environmental conditions, monitoring objectives, and total cost of ownership over the transformer’s operational life.
Fiber optic temperature sensor, Intelligent monitoring system, Distributed fiber optic manufacturer in China
 |
 |
 |
